Bidhive logo

What’s the difference between a tender, bid and proposal?

October 2, 2024

In this article we explain the difference between bids, tenders and proposals with a straightforward list of definitions every company needs to know.

Why terminology matters

The first thing to realise is that terms vary from organisation to organisation and from country to country. They also depend to some extent on the background and skill set of the person involved.

What is a tender?

Tendering is an approach to a formal, competitive procurement opportunity to gain significant new or repeat business. It’s a process where buyers (the procurement department) publish a formal notice for goods/services and invites other parties (through the open market, or by limited or closed invitation) to submit a bid to provide those goods or services.  This is undertaken ‘at arms’ length’ to provide a level playing field for all bidders. Once a bidder registers for the opportunity, they are issued with identical documentation which includes, but is not limited to, the request for tender, the scope of work (or specifications), response schedule/template, and a draft Conditions of Contract. The tender process is run according to a timeline with a strict deadline.  Final submissions – if deemed compliant – run through a formal evaluation process involving a panel who then shortlist. Final applicants are then assessed usually against price and non-price (quality) criteria, with the highest scoring bidder being awarded the contract award.

What is a bid?

Bidding is the formal process of managing a tender opportunity. The term bid or bidding can also relate to the written offer submitted in response to a request or invitation to tender. As mentioned above, the submitted bid is evaluated against a set of criteria described in the request or invitation to tender. It might be a single stage process, or a multi-stage process which begins with an open competition which then progresses to shortlist, presentation and negotiation.

Bidding may involve staff from across the whole breadth of one or more organisations. A Bid Manager will usually oversee the end-to-end process, which may start as early as capture (strategically identifying the opportunity) to post-bid feedback/debrief. Their role may be one of a manager, or they may be hands-on and perform the proposal writing function as well.

The Bid Manager needs to interact with many types of specialists – from technical to legal, finance (or estimating teams), and senior management, and must understand their roles, responsibilities, and what they can and cannot be asked to deliver.

What is a proposal?

A proposal is a written offer from a seller/vendor to a prospective buyer. It is a critical step in the business-to-business (B2B) sales process (sometimes the only step); or in the case of business-to-government (B2G) when a provider has already been successful with their bid to become a preferred supplier, and then moves to a request for quote stage for subsequent engagements.  Proposals are client-centric selling documents which usually contain a schedule of fees – these are highly tailored and solutions-oriented to the buyer’s requirements.

What are the key roles in the bid process?

Bid Manager

The Bid Manager takes full ownership of the entire bid program. Sometimes, this may involve identifying and converting significant business opportunities (in some organisations there may even be a dedicated Capture Manager who performs this role), to delivering bid responses – including research, information gathering, and strategic messaging prior to the bid being released. Responsibilities include overseeing best practice processes and procedures, managing multiple resources – sometimes cross-functional, cross-jurisdictional, and even across companies or the supply chain.

As a leadership position, the Bid Manager – who must feel at ease working with executives and the Board – requires strong people management skills, the ability to deal with complex business relationships and competing priorities, and the capability to deliver a strong winning business case to the client in a high-stress environment within tight time frames.

Bid Coordinator

A bid shares many characteristics of a project due to its defined beginning and end point, objectives, roles, responsibilities, milestones, and deliverables. For this reason, some organisations assign a dedicated person to coordinate all the moving parts of the documented bid response.

Proposal Writer

Proposal Writers are usually tasked with pulling together pre-existing information or creating custom content and tailoring it to the client’s needs. Generally, a proposal includes a summary, then identifies the problem or business opportunity, defines the solution and how it will work (the methodology or project plan together with performance criteria), budget/pricing, and organisational details, including names and descriptions of credentials (past performance) and the expertise of the individuals who will be responsible for managing and performing the work.

Other key terms

Business profile or corporate credentials

A business profile or corporate credentials is a written document that presents a snapshot of your company. It essentially serves as a resume for your business.

Capability statement

Similar to a business profile but usually tailored to the audience or the contract requirements. It describes the business’ capabilities and experience, including who you are, what you do, and how you are different from your competitors. Companies often develop many different capability statements tailored to the industry verticals, market sectors or geographic regions in which they operate.

Technical specialist

Also referred to as ‘subject matter experts’, technical specialists are usually industry-specific and are central to developing the client solution. Their focus is on design and functionality rather than the sell. In the IT space, they might be systems programmers or network designers; for major infrastructure, they may be civil engineers.

Technical writer

Technical Writers are professional communicators skilled at translating technical language into plain English instructions for the everyday user of a product or service. The Technical Writer and Bid Manager work closely with Technical Specialists to scope their information requirements to ensure it contributes positively to the Bid.

The role of technology solutions to automate the process

While many technology solutions, such as Request for Proposal software, exist to support the proposal process, few are adept at addressing the complex, multi-stepped nature of tenders and bidding.

The Bidhive bid management solution stands out in a crowded proposal market by providing a fit-for-purpose system that supports your team across all steps and phases of the process. This includes overseeing the bid process from start to finish, encompassing bid strategy, managing Addendum (updates or changes to tender documentation), resource capacity, and client debrief sessions. Our system also facilitates the development and maintenance of non-technical content, the editing of technical schedules, and ensures that submission deadlines are consistently met.

Additionally, with the assistance of AI tools, Bidhive reviews and analyses client documentation, such as scope of works, specifications, and service agreements, and it encourages collaboration with internal teams and subject matter experts to prepare pre-bid capture plans, successful bid responses and performance and status reports. By leveraging such comprehensive and sophisticated technology solutions, we are able to streamline the tendering process, enhance efficiency, and ultimately deliver superior outcomes.

 

Breaking down the myth that bidding is just proposal writing 

There's a pervasive myth in business development that persists: proposal writing is the same as bidding. This misconception can lead organisations astray, misdirecting their efforts - including hiring and digital adoption strategies - on focusing narrowly on the...

Mastering the art of tendering with Bidhive: Your comprehensive bid management solution

Tendering is becoming more competitive. Small to medium businesses have greater access to opportunities like never before, and generative AI solutions are helping us save time in drafting.  With the playing field being increasingly levelled, having an edge can make...

Tendering for purpose-led organisations: Aligning bidding processes with mission-driven goals

For organisations operating across multiple service lines or market sectors, especially those servicing the public sector or highly regulated industries, the process of going to market via public, limited, or closed tender to secure contracts is often...

Better together: The business case for generative AI and data analytics in bidding

The argument: Backed by research Recent research findings by McKinsey & Company provides compelling evidence for the business case of integrating Generative AI and data analytics into organisational processes, including bidding. The findings give us insight into...

Enhancing bid processes with AI: Streamlining SME engagement and proposal quality

Incorporating subject matter experts (SMEs) into the bid process is crucial for creating compelling and competitive proposals. Given SMEs often have full-time day jobs to juggle alongside the many demands of ad-hoc proposal requests, bid managers and proposal managers...

Major projects in Australia: Where to find the opportunities

Australia continues to be a focal point for numerous major projects across various sectors, offering vast opportunities for domestic and international investors, service providers, and professionals. Here's an overview of key areas where major opportunities are...

Unveiling the Power of Real-Time Procurement Data: Lessons from Bidhive

Procurement is the backbone of many industries, enabling businesses to secure the necessary goods and services to operate successfully. Today, with vast technological advancements, the integration of digital solutions has become a crucial part of procurement processes...

Empowering Australian SMEs: Government to Revamp Procurement Rules to Level the Playing Field

New reforms to Commonwealth Procurement Rules in Australia aim to empower SMEs with easier access to government contracts, support local manufacturing, and stimulate economic growth.

International trade agreements and competitive global bidding: What you need to know

For any capture or bid manager who has found themselves in a new role with a multinational or a company that conducts business internationally, understanding international trade agreements is essential.  These agreements have become game-changers for securing...

Harnessing the Power of Data-Driven Bid Narratives

Generative AI has opened up a massive market for prospective bidders who could previously ill-afford to put their livelihoods on hold to respond to tender.  This has all changed with an array of tools that help companies automate, synthesise, draft and manage the...
Share This